Page 1 of 1

single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 26 Mar 2024, 18:52
by MichelRE
I have chords played in the strings, quarter note value.
almost all happen on the beat... except for one, which is off by half a beat.

I need to know whether I should write it as I would "normally" write an off-beat note (ie: tied values), or if I should use a single value.

In the image,violin 2 have the single value, while violas have the tied notes.

Would writing it as the 2nd violins be correct? (both measures are in 3/4)

I always get confused with the rules about notes across beat boundaries in time signatures other than 4/4.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 26 Mar 2024, 22:03
by David Ward
I would personally find the single value (vln. 2) clear and simple, and I would expect to write it; but I'm not certain of the officially approved (by whom?) rule.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 26 Mar 2024, 23:43
by MichelRE
yeah, that's why I'm asking hehehehe.

I find the single note clearer, but one never knows, do one.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 27 Mar 2024, 03:05
by John Ruggero
Single note.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 27 Mar 2024, 05:32
by hautbois baryton
I would go with single note, since the tied note is going to prompt questions.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 27 Mar 2024, 08:22
by OCTO
Single note.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 27 Mar 2024, 09:05
by MichelRE
oh thank-you all!

I'm glad that the nagging voice in the back of my mind was insisting I ask the forum gurus.

I really hated the look of the tied notes.

Re: single note or tied note question (syncopation)

Posted: 31 Mar 2024, 02:13
by JJP
I’m late to the party, but here’s another vote for the single note.