Seconds are fine as-is: one solution could be starting the bar with a Gb instead of an F#, but I’m not entirely sure it’s necessary.
In the firsts I’d probably go with B C# Eb: I don’t particularly like writing or reading diminished seconds, and to me the diminished third that’s necessary to switch from sharps to flats in a whole tone scale is easiest to parse when the diminished third is placed between two notes that have to have accidentals.
Accidental spelling question
Re: Accidental spelling question
Primarily an orchestral bassist, but I do copying and engraving work on the side
14" M4 Pro Macbook Pro, Dorico 6 (former Sibelius user)
14" M4 Pro Macbook Pro, Dorico 6 (former Sibelius user)
Re: Accidental spelling question
I remember playing operas by Wagner and Strauss, they are full of such accidentals.
Finale 27.5 • Sibelius 2026.2• MuseScore 4+ • Logic Pro X+ • Ableton Live 12+ • Digital Performer 11 /// MacOS Monterey (secondary in use systems: Fedora 35, Windows 10)
Re: Accidental spelling question
LOL Wagner and Strauss are also replete with double (s)harps and double flats!!!
Last edited by MichelRE on 07 Sep 2026, 15:07, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Accidental spelling question
Sometimes sextuple harps...
Re: Accidental spelling question
LOL, that was a typo (for some reason, if I don't strike the "S" key on my keyboard in just a very specific direction, it doesn't respond.)
- Fred G. Unn
- Posts: 589
- Joined: 05 Oct 2015, 13:24
- Location: NYCish
Re: Accidental spelling question
Vln. II is just C# ascending melodic minor starting on E (up to the Eb) so one option could be to use that spelling in that bar. It uses a B# but would be easily read as it's a standard scale that they practice every day. Alternatively, just switch the Gb to F# and leave the whole bar as flats.MichelRE wrote: 04 Sep 2026, 14:39 I can't say "well this passage is in X-minor, therefore I need to use X-spelling."
I'm trying to make READING the passage as easy on the eyes as possible for the performers.
For Vln. I, I think with whole tone scales I'm more used to seeing sharps when this is ascending, and then using D# - F natural, and using flats with Db - B natural when descending. Here are a couple of examples from a Guy Lacour etude:
I think what you have is easily enough read though, just presenting some rationale behind other options.