Page 1 of 2

Notating a bar

Posted: 03 Dec 2021, 23:39
by Hector Pascal
Hi all,
I have composed this 9/8 bar of piano music. Am I on the right track in regard to its notation?
The top staff is treble clef and the bottom staff is bass clef. As for the slur and the crescendo, I squeezed them in, but am open to other positions.
Screen Shot 2021-12-04 at 10.42.52 am.png
Screen Shot 2021-12-04 at 10.42.52 am.png (263.49 KiB) Viewed 11420 times
Thanks and best wishes,
Hector.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 04 Dec 2021, 13:57
by Schonbergian
I would remove the rests in the latter third of the measure as they add visual clutter and the beaming already conveys distribution between the hands.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 04 Dec 2021, 16:26
by John Ruggero
example.jpeg
example.jpeg (142.67 KiB) Viewed 11390 times

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 05 Dec 2021, 21:55
by Hector Pascal
Beautiful! Thanks all :)
Cheers,
HP.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 08 Dec 2021, 12:06
by benwiggy
Any reason for the small noteheads?

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 08 Dec 2021, 13:23
by John Ruggero
Great question. To avoid using a tuplet bracket, since I was assuming that a precise rhythm was really not to the point here and perhaps even undesirable. (If the composer desires an exact rhythm, he would use large notes and a tuplet bracket.) The notes are really a written-out arpeggio of voices "below" the final chord, whether or not the composer wants them held through with the pedal, and there is a tradition of writing out such arpeggios and roulades in small notes.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 08 Dec 2021, 13:50
by Anders Hedelin
I can see the reason why the full-sized B flat in the left hand should be matched with an eighth rest in the right hand, but since the arpeggio shares both staves, is it necessary? It made me a little bit confused at first, I have to admit.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 08 Dec 2021, 17:10
by MalteM
John Ruggero wrote: 04 Dec 2021, 16:26 example.jpeg
IMHO you need those hooks for hand distribution, the stem directions and beaming are clear enough.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 08 Dec 2021, 17:12
by John Ruggero
The rest was troublesome to me too, Anders. I had considered making it a dotted eighth-rest, but that wouldn't be quite correct either. So if you find it confusing and are OK with leaving it out, that's good enough for me.

Re: Notating a bar

Posted: 08 Dec 2021, 17:19
by John Ruggero
MaiteM, if you meant that the hooks are unnecessary, you may be right. If they are overkill it would be great to leave them out. I just wasn't completely sure that it was clear enough without them or r.h. and l.h. indications.