Clef design comparision

[John Ruggero]

I got a little seasick looking at those rotating clefs!

[Fred G. Unn]

In light of the earlier discussion on rotation, number three from the left is the best one to me.

+1, I agree.

[Vaughan]

I agree, both with Knut and Fred, and with John about the seasickness.

[OCTO]

I agree, both with Knut and Fred, and with John about the seasickness.

:D I agree too!
I have noticed that clefs in old editions...

[John Ruggero]

And I agree with everyone about everything!

[Schneider]

Hi Prok,

Here is my contribution of [...]

I like #3. Can I use it ? Is there any copyrights ?

[prokofiev]

i release it as GPL. you can use as you wish, but keeping GPL.

[Schneider]

Thank you

[Schneider]

I sometimes copy clef shapes I like.
Here are some examples:

g-clefs.png (42.05 KiB) Viewed 13266 times

By the way, when I copied the Henle clef I was surprised by the poor quality of the original drawing:

henle comparision.png (131.49 KiB) Viewed 13266 times

[tisimst]

I've wondered the same thing, Pierre, about the Henle treble clef. I think the design has been around for a while, so it could just be a result of less sophisticated tools than we have now. On the other hand, when printed out, the blemishes aren't that noticeable in the original design, but I definitely like your corrections.